Skip to main content

Parental Rights, Education, American Values, Culture War

Greg Gutfeld Sounds the Alarm on Ideology in America’s Classrooms

Greg Gutfeld’s criticism of ideological approaches to race and education raises a larger question: what values should America’s schools teach?
 | 

There are moments when political commentary stops being entertainment.

For Greg Gutfeld, one of Fox News’ most recognizable personalities, the subject of education and ideological influence in America’s schools has been one of those moments for years.

Gutfeld has repeatedly criticized what he sees as the growing tendency to interpret education, achievement, race and American institutions through an ideological lens. In a 2023 Gutfeld! segment, for example, he attacked “equitable grading” and criticized arguments that traditional academic expectations can represent “white privilege.” He also highlighted a Washington school-board debate over claims involving “white supremacy culture.”

Those arguments deserve more than a television punchline.

They deserve a serious conversation.

The Question Parents Cannot Ignore

At the center of the controversy is a simple question:

What is the purpose of education?

Is the primary responsibility of a school to teach children how to read, write, calculate, reason, investigate evidence and understand history?

Or should schools also be responsible for teaching children how to interpret society through a particular political or racial framework?

Reasonable Americans can disagree about where that line should be drawn.

But parents have every right to ask what their children are being taught—and schools have a responsibility to answer honestly.

That is not extremism.

That is parental involvement.

When Achievement Becomes a Political Argument

One of the issues Gutfeld has repeatedly challenged is the idea that traditional academic standards can themselves be expressions of racial privilege.

His criticism is not new. Fox has previously documented his objections to educational approaches that characterize conventional expectations such as hard work, punctuality and achievement through the language of “white privilege.”

This is where the debate becomes particularly important.

America should be careful about sending children the message that achievement itself is morally suspect.

A child who studies hard should be encouraged.

A student who excels at mathematics should be celebrated.

A young person who reads widely, writes well, solves difficult problems or earns a scholarship should be told that those accomplishments matter.

None of those things should depend upon race.

The American ideal is not that every child will produce the same outcome.

It is that every child should have the opportunity to pursue excellence.

The Difference Between Teaching History and Teaching Guilt

There is another distinction worth protecting.

America has a complicated history.

Slavery was evil. Segregation was wrong. Racial discrimination has existed throughout American history. Those realities should be taught honestly.

But teaching history is different from teaching children that they are personally responsible for the sins of people who lived before they were born.

Children should learn about America’s failures and its achievements.

They should learn about slavery and the abolition movement.

They should learn about segregation and the civil-rights movement.

They should learn about the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the sacrifices of American soldiers, the expansion of individual liberty and the generations of Americans who worked to make the country more equal.

A serious education does not require pretending America has always been perfect.

Nor does it require teaching children that America is fundamentally evil.

Both extremes fail children.

Parents Have a Right to Ask Questions

The most constructive response is not to demand that every classroom become politically conservative.

It is to insist that classrooms remain places where children can learn without being pressured into adopting a particular political worldview.

Parents should be able to ask:

  • What curriculum is being used?
  • What books are assigned?
  • What outside materials are being presented?
  • How are race and American history being taught?
  • Are students being encouraged to ask questions?
  • Are competing perspectives presented fairly?
  • Are academic standards being maintained?
  • Is political advocacy being separated from instruction?
  • Are parents being given meaningful transparency?

These are reasonable questions regardless of a parent’s political affiliation.

The Debate Over Critical Race Theory

Gutfeld has also been a longtime critic of critical race theory and related concepts. In a 2020 Fox News opinion piece, he argued that CRT could replace traditional concepts of equality with a framework centered on grievance and racial identity.

Whether someone agrees with that assessment or not, the broader debate is real.

Academic discussions of race, inequality and privilege are not inherently illegitimate. There is serious scholarship examining how race and institutions interact, including research examining the relationship between academic achievement, race and concepts of white supremacy.

But legitimate scholarship does not mean every curriculum is automatically legitimate.

The question should always be:

What exactly are children being taught?

That question should be answered with evidence rather than slogans.

America Does Not Need to Be Ashamed of Excellence

There is nothing wrong with teaching children to work hard.

There is nothing wrong with teaching them that character matters.

There is nothing wrong with teaching them that responsibility matters.

There is nothing wrong with teaching them that achievement matters.

And there is nothing wrong with teaching them to love their country while also understanding its imperfections.

Those principles are not inherently Republican or Democrat.

They are not inherently conservative or liberal.

They are part of a broader American tradition that places enormous value on individual responsibility, opportunity and self-government.

The goal should not be to manufacture patriotic children.

Nor should it be to manufacture children who distrust their country.

The goal should be to educate young Americans well enough that they can think for themselves.

The Responsibility Belongs to Parents, Too

This is where the conversation needs to move beyond television personalities.

Greg Gutfeld can raise the alarm. Politicians can debate education policy. School boards can adopt a curriculum. Teachers can teach. But parents ultimately have the responsibility to know what their children are learning. That means attending school board meetings. Reading curriculum documents. Talking with teachers. Reading the books. Asking questions.

And, perhaps most importantly, talking with their children.

Parents should not outsource the moral and intellectual development of their children entirely to government schools, private schools, universities, social media or television personalities.

Education is too important.

The Real Fight Is Over the Mind

The most consequential battles in a free society are not always fought on battlefields.

They are fought over ideas.

They are fought over what children are taught about responsibility, freedom, citizenship, history and human dignity.

That does not mean every disagreement is a war.

It means Americans should pay attention.

Gutfeld’s broader argument about education is ultimately a challenge to complacency: parents should know what is happening in their children’s classrooms and should be willing to speak when they believe something is wrong.

That is not a call for censorship.

It is a call for participation.

America’s children deserve an education that teaches them to think rather than tells them what to think.

They deserve to understand America’s failures without being taught to hate their country.

They deserve to understand racism without being reduced to racial categories themselves.

They deserve high academic standards without being told that excellence is something to apologize for.

And they deserve parents who are willing to pay attention.

The answer is not panic.

The answer is not silence.

The answer is engagement.

Parents should show up.

Ask questions.

Demand transparency.

Read the curriculum.

Know what their children are being taught.

And then teach their children the most important lesson of all:

Think for yourself. Know your history. Love your country. And never surrender your ability to question authority.

That is how a free people remains free.